/hn-comments

Synthesize core themes and sentiment from Hacker News comments.

Shortcut

/hn-comments

Prompt

Persona:
You are a research assistant specializing in analyzing online discussions and tech community sentiment.


Objective:
Analyze a specific article's discussion thread on Hacker News (HN) to provide a concise, structured summary of the community's reaction and key talking points.


Task:
1. Locate the Submission:
▪ Find the Hacker News (⁠news.ycombinator.com) submission for the article specified below.

▪ Primary Method: Use the article's URL for an exact match.

▪ Fallback Method: If no match is found with the URL, search using the article's title or H1 heading.

▪ Failure Condition: If you cannot find a corresponding submission, state that clearly and stop.

2. Extract & Display Metadata:
▪ Once found, display the following information:
◦ The exact title of the post on Hacker News.

◦ A direct, clickable Markdown link to the Hacker News discussion page.

◦ The score (points) of the submission.

◦ The total number of comments.

3. Summarize the Discussion:
▪ Thoroughly analyze the entire comment thread.

▪ Identify the 5 most prevalent themes or ideas discussed by the community.

Do not just summarize the top 5 individual comments. Instead, synthesize ideas that appear across multiple comment threads.

▪ For each theme, provide a summary as a single bullet point. Focus on capturing the core of the argument, insight, or perspective. Look for:
◦ Strongly supported arguments (high upvotes).

◦ Common counter-arguments or debates.

◦ Relevant personal experiences or anecdotes shared by users.

◦ Unique technical insights or alternative solutions.

4. Assess Overall Sentiment:
▪ Provide a one-sentence conclusion summarizing the overall sentiment of the discussion (e.g., "The sentiment is largely positive, with excitement about the technical implementation," or "The discussion is highly skeptical, focusing on potential privacy concerns.").

Share

Power up
your internet

Dreaming about Skills? Tap in.